Hi there!
Today I would like to invite You for a review of a speaker I was awaiting quite
anxiously. The reason for my anxiousness was, for one, the very promising tech
specification of the speaker itself, and for two, the fact that it was designed
and engineered by no other than Mr. Phil Jones, a man responsible for few
groundbreaking speakers like Acoustic Energy AE 1 and AAD 7001i to name two.
The speaker we are talking about today is AirPulse A200 or AirPulse Model One
if You are in America. My main question for this review is this: is the premium price (999$) of
AirPulse A200 justified by its performance, or is the involvement of Mr. Jones
just a marketing gimmick used to rip You of Your hard-earned money? Let’s find
out!
AirPulse
A200 (this is the name I will use for this review) is first standalone model
created by Phil Jones in full cooperation with Edifier. Together, under AirPulse brand, they aim to create high end active
speakers with impeccable sound quality at reasonable price. AirPulse A200 is a two-way
active speaker, designed around big 3inch ribbon tweeter (like the one found in
much more expensive AAD 7001i speaker) recessed into a big horn and moved by
strong, rare earth magnet. Horn is used to improve efficiency of the tweeter
and to control the directivity of the soundwaves coming from the ribbon, thus
helping to reduce the diffractions from nearby surfaces like desks and
ceilings, that would negatively impact the sound (how this impacts the sound of
A200 will be mentioned later in the listening section). As a partner in crime
for the ribbon tweeter, Jones chose a 5.5 inch aluminum woofer, again moved by
big, underhung magnet, to deal with low to mid frequencies. Each driver used
here has its own amplifier. Each ribbon tweeter is powered by modest 10W
amplifier and each woofer by beefier 55W amplifier. This gives a total of 130W
of power for whole system. Signal coming to the amps is split by active
crossovers and those crossovers are controlled by Digital Signal Processing
module. To feed the signal we can use a whole plethora of inputs including both
digital (coaxial, Toslink, and wireless Bluetooth 4.0 with Apt-X) as well as
analogue ones (RCA and XLR). Too bad Aipulse, in Edifier style, omitted the USB
input that would make this speaker a total feature beast. There is also a lack
of dedicated subwoofer output, which is pity again.
All that
jazz (drivers and electronics) are enclosed in two big (for a two-way speaker with
only 5.5inch woofer) speaker boxes. Those boxes are built from 1 inch (!) thick
MDF, with additional internal bracing and sound deadening foam used inside to
further reduce the impact of enclosures on the sound. This thing is solid. One
thing I do have to admit thought is that I expected a bit more stylish look
from A200. What I found instead is rather restrained speaker that looks more
like a pimped-up studio monitor than Hi-Fi speaker in terms of esthetics. It is
not bad looking speaker at all but certainly will not win any beauty contests
either. Cheery wood vinyl used to cover side panels look OK and overall A200 is
an example of function over form.
AirPulse
A200 comes double boxed, and the speakers are additionally protected by fabric
cloth and plastic bags. Inside the boxes, except for the speakers and remote,
we will also find two connection cables (RCA to 3.5mm jack and RCA to RCA) as
well as toslink cable and solid, 6 meters long speaker cable used to connect
master speaker with its slave. To control the functions of the speakers we can
use either a small remote, made of good quality plastic, or the dials on the
back of master speaker. Remote itself is very compact and has ergonomic shape.
Also, rubber buttons on remote have nice feeling to them. My only gripe with
remote is that I would like to see use of aluminum instead of plastic. Unlike
the Edifier S2000 Pro I reviewed few months ago, A200 has no EQ profiles to
choose from so the only way we can impact the sound of A200 is by two dials on
the back of master speaker, one is responsible for treble and the other is
responsible for bass. All dials are made of nicely machined aluminum and look
very good. Again, too bad that dials on the back are so nicely done while
remote we will touch and use very often is made of plastic (good quality
plastic but still…).
After
setting up the speakers and connecting them, I checked the hiss level, and I am
happy to report that the hiss level is very low (significantly lower than JBL
LSR305 or KRK RP5 G3 for example). A200 is a speaker will not be a problem even
from very close range in quiet rooms. Big relief.
After few
days of casual listening and letting the speakers loosen up a bit, I already
knew that all the technological gibberish from the description of the
speakers has a purpose and that it delivers very good sound quality. How good?
Well, let’s start with describing the overall character of Airpulse A200, which
in fact is almost no character at all. A200 is inherently neutral and lightning
fast from top to bottom, it transforms from track to track from album to album,
giving very honest representation of the actual sound music reproduced. Artist wanted
to give his track a dark and moody tone with thick warm bass? Here You have it,
A200 plays exactly that. Someone decided to add too much upper midrange and top
end, making the music sound a bit too bright? You will hear it on A200
perfectly. A200 is like chameleon in this regard, it will sound wonderful with well-produced
tracks, but with those badly produced things may get ugly. This is another
thing about A200, except for looks, that brings them closer to good studio
monitors than to typical Hi Fi speakers. It is not a speaker that makes
everything sound nice or inoffensive while taking away the real character of
the music in the process.
Let’s focus now on each sound characteristic separately. Bass response? Deep, deepest from a speaker with 5 inch woofer I have experienced. What about the tone of bass, the details? Also, top notch, bass is very tight, focused and tuneful, stops when it needs and has very little coloration (no bass reflex noise even on high volume). When necessary, bass is fast and impactful or warm and cozy, whatever the track demands. Midrange? Very clear and transparent with excellent detail, realistic and focused. Even when playing complex levered music, it never loosed composure or coherence. Top end? Again, very detailed, well focused and extended far higher than most of the speakers I have heard. If I wanted to be picky than I would say that in the neutral tone setup the top end draws a bit too much attention to itself, but that is easy to adjust using tone controls for treble to reach desirable balance. Ribbon tweeters have a reputation of producing very good soundstage and A200 further solidifies this. Soundstage produced by A200 is the best I have heard yet, word holographic comes to mind and for a good reason. Height and width are very impressive, but what is even more impressive is the depth A200 produces. Sound appears in front of the speakers, in line with the speakers or in layers far behind them. Images are always very well defined and focused, detached from the speakers themselves. Impressive stuff.
Big credit
for such a great soundstageing is due to the ribbon tweeter and the horn used
to project the sound, but as with everything in life this must come at a price.
The price here is that sound of Airpulse is very directional in the vertical
axis. Horns beam the sound coming from ribbons to vertically narrow, well
defined space, so if You move outside of it that sound becomes dull.
Horizontally situation is much better, and there is wide sweet spot where You
can move to the sides of the center without compromising the soundstage. Airpulse A200 works as well nearfield as it
does midfield, keeping all the good characteristics in both setups. A200 has no
problem of filling bigger spaces with authoritative sound. Even though it has
modest 65W per speaker, it is very efficient speaker using every drop of power
to its advantage. I often found myself listening to them louder than I would
normally do without realizing it, at least until I tried to speak or someone
was trying to speak to me. This is a testament on how little distortion they have
across the whole frequency range even at high volumes.
During my
tests, I have compared AirPulse with three different speakers. Two of them You
already know from my previous test, they are Klipsch R15PM and JBL LSR305. The
third speaker was brought especially for this occasion. Because the speakers I
have available for comparisons are significantly cheaper than A200, I felt that
to give it proper opponent I need something closer to its price level. After
some consideration, I decided it is a good opportunity to finally get my hands on
KEF X300A Wireless. KEF will be briefly mentioned here, but the full review
will come next month.
Let’s start
with weakest link in this trio, Klipsch R15PM. From build quality stand point
of view AirPulse feels much more solid. A200 is much heavier and the box feels
much more rigid. Soundwise, AirPulse clearly showed all the limitations R15PM
has, namely very weak bass response, a bit of honky colorations to midrange,
flat soundstageing and flat dynamics. First off, the midrange of A200 sounds
much more natural and realistic, with more details and focus. Treble of A200
extends much higher, has more air and details. AirPulse also has lower extended
bass that can kick much harder with more dynamic slam and precision. AirPulse
can reach much higher volume levels without any changes to sound quality, focus
or dynamic ability. A200 is clearly a superior speaker to R15PM.
Next one
for comparisons was my long-time budget benchmark, JBL LSR305. As with Klipsch,
the difference in build quality was very significant, and it was expected
considering the price difference. Especially the plastic front panel of JBL
sticks out as a sore thumb in comparison. AirPulse also produced significantly
less hiss than JBL. Soundwise, JBL managed to come much closer to AirPulse than
Klipsch, especially in the bass department, where JBL showed that it can reach
almost as low, at least on normal levels, with authority. The biggest
difference in bass between A200 and LSR305 was the overall focus and tightness.
A200 rendered the kick drums and bass guitars more realistically with better
separation. Moving up to the midrange, when switching directly from A200 to JBL,
I could hear the plastic front panel in JBL coloring the sound slightly.
AirPulse has faster, more open, more focused and more realistic midrange with
more presence in upper ranges. JBL’s top is less airy and rolls off earlier
leaving the overall sound signature slightly darker. A200 also produces more
impressive soundstage with more precise and better defined images, more height and
depth. Both can play loud, but A200 goes few decibels louder without any
distortions. Overall Airpulse is a big improvement over JBL in terms of build
quality, features and more importantly sound quality.
KEF X300A
Wireless, unlike JBL and Klipsch, is a speaker that comes much closer to
AirPulse in price, so I expected it to perform on similar level. After
comparing them side by side I must say that X300A sits somewhere in between JBL
and AirPulse when it comes to sound quality but it is closer to JBL though. Esthetically
KEF is more pleasing than AirPulse, especially in white finish, while the build
quality is on comparable level. X300A is more compact speaker, which will be important
especially in nearfield setups. Soundwise, X300A is solid performer but trails
a bit behind A200 in few key areas. For one, KEF has its own sound signature,
it is not as neutral as A200 is. There is more presence and weight in lower
midrange in KEF, while upper midrange is slightly recessed and the top end is
rolled off compared to AirPulse. Bass quality in both is similar but A200 has a
touch more focus, punch and extension. Vocals on KEF are rendered more forward
and a bit heavier with a hint of nasal and honky colorations. KEFs top end
rolls off much faster than in A200, AirPulse is much more open and airy in
comparison. KEF throws nice soundstage but lacks a bit of height, depth and
precision to compete with AirPulse. Overall A200 is more neutral, more balanced
and more precise speaker.
Conclusion
AirPulse A200 is
fantastically neutral speaker, with open, detailed and transparent sound from top to bottom. Add to that very solid build quality and rich set of features, and suddenly its steep price
becomes much more reasonable. I was reluctant to return them, I wish I had them for longer. AirPulse A200 lands on top of my wish list to become
my new benchmark speaker soon (gotta start saving those pennies), and from now on I am looking forward to next
products from AirPulse and Mr. Phil Jones without any anxiety;) Highly recommended.
Overall
score 9,25/10
Pros:
-Transparent,
honest and neutral sound
-Very good
bass response, tight and punchy
-Great
soundstage
-Very good
build quality and lots of useful features
-Good value
for money
Cons:
-Looks more like a studio monitor more than a typical HiFi speaker
-May be a
bit too much in the top end for some
-USB input
and sub out would be nice
-Vertically
narrow sound dispersion
Many thanks to Digital Stereophony for their insightful and informative review of the new Airpulse Model One by Phil Jones. The pictures reveal a robust classic in the genre, a plug and play or wireless high end, his res audio system with remote control. This level of audiophilia has never been so affordable. What country are you in?
OdpowiedzUsuńI agree, Aiprulse is great value for money, even though it is not cheap. Greetings from Poland!
UsuńHi, I've enjoyed reading your reviews (and comments in Youtube). Given the speakers you've listened and compared, what would be the one you would spend your money on (even if you had to save up) for using with a PC (gaming, movies, music)? Must have wired and wireless capabilities. Thanks and keep up the great reviews :D
OdpowiedzUsuńHi. For all in one multimedia speaker I would suggest either Edifier S1000DB or S2000 Pro. The latter is more expensive but it is worth the extra over S1000DB. Cheers!
UsuńHi Michał!
OdpowiedzUsuńThank you for all the good work you've done.
I'm planning to change my trustworthy Sven Royal 2. Which of the speakers you would recommend? I am currently looking at Edifier A200, S2000 Pro and Klipsch R15PM. Do I need to upgrade at all?)))
Thanks.
A good set of speakers can help turn your PC into the ultimate home entertainment. Looking for
OdpowiedzUsuńBest Computer Speakers that are Compact, Well-Designed, and Produce Great Sound?
best computer speakers
Hi, just wanted to say thanks for making these reviews. Been hunting around for a pair of powered speakers for the living room and your youtube channel has helped a lot.
OdpowiedzUsuń